banana chocolate mug cake! also known as: easy dessert that totally satisfies my baked good AND chocolate cravings, simultaneously, without sugar poisoning me! bonuses include being: naturally sweetened; gluten free; dairy free (though butter is an option and i will tell you how the mug cake turns out differently if you use it); egg free; grain free; paleo, vegan, and soy free if you want it to be, …what else?
oh! delicious! despite/because of all of that, this banana chocolate mug cake is totally delicious. i’ve never been happier to have a stockpile of frozen bananas.
i don’t remember for certain, but i’m pretty sure this banana chocolate mug cake started as an after dinner craving for a baked good (with chocolate, obviously), that wouldn’t make me feel ill just before going to bed.
it turns out i’m pretty sensitive to sugar, and several cookie recipes that i’ve tried to make over the past few months have not made it past go because i just can’t bear to keep testing them, because i feel so sugar poisoned after eating a few cookies. and my husband, usually a reliable baked good tester, isn’t that into them because they aren’t sweet enough for his taste. bummer for both of us!
so, it was from those shaky grounds that this banana chocolate mug cake was born. and, if i may say, it’s a total winner. at this point, i’ve tested about 10 different versions so let me run through the yummy options (we’ll just skip those first few trials…)
- oil vs. butter: i tested both extra light olive oil (for its neutral flavor) and butter, expecting to prefer butter. surprise! i liked the oil version better. the oil version had more chocolate flavor and a nicer, more cake-like crumb. the butter version had a stronger banana flavor and a gooier texture.
- natural vs. dutch processed cocoa powder: once i knew that i preferred oil, i tried both types of cocoa powder in a mug cake made with oil and preferred the natural cocoa powder version. the chocolate flavor was stronger and the texture was more cake-like whereas the dutch processed cocoa produced a gooier cake, similar to using butter.
- baking powder vs. baking soda + cream of tartar: baking powder usually contains corn starch and is not paleo. if either of those attributes bother you, go with the baking soda + cream of tartar option. otherwise, baking powder is convenient and i didn’t notice a difference between mug cakes made with either option.
- almond butter vs. pecan butter: yes, pecan butter is a thing and yes it is delicious. that said, because i didn’t already have a jar of it my fridge, i preferred almond butter for convenience and because my mini food processor doesn’t produce a very smooth pecan butter. but both are delicious and effective.
- substitutions i didn’t try but would love you to comment on if you do:
- using cornstarch instead of arrowroot starch – seems like it would work; wouldn’t be paleo.
- using coconut oil instead of oil or butter – seems like it would work, may impact texture, would make the mug cake taste like coconut (depending on how refined your coconut oil is).
hopefully that helps set you off on the path towards your favorite version of banana chocolate mug cake! i’m so happy i’ve found mine and can now enjoy dessert without being sugar poisoned.
did you make this recipe? i’d love to know what you think of it! leave a comment below and share a picture on instagram with the hashtag #tastyseasons.
please note this page contains affiliate links, which means that if you make a purchase after clicking from here, i will earn a small commission from amazon at no additional charge to you. i only link to products that i use and love. thank you for supporting tasty seasons!